.png){kind=logo}
.png){kind=logo}
.png)
.png)
330. Owned Channels, Not Ads, Built a 75% Return Customer Rate - Aaron Argueta, Bailey's CBD for Pets
Last month, 75% of the customers who bought on Bailey's CBD for Pets had bought before. That's the number most brands chase after growth stalls. Bailey's has been building towards it for 10 years, because paid media in CBD was never available to them in the first place.
Aaron Argueta is co-founder and CMO of Bailey's CBD for Pets, a bootstrapped pet wellness brand in Orange County, Southern California. He runs the company with his business partner Jay. Most of the headcount sits in manufacturing and fulfilment, and everything else, web development, email, affiliate management and SEO, runs through agencies. Ten years of trading in a heavily restricted category has produced a growth model built almost entirely on assets a platform can't switch off.
Experience compounds faster than capital
Aaron's view on what actually creates advantage in a hard category is direct. Some brands arrive with funding and expect capital to solve the problem. Bailey's arrived with time. A decade of dealing with rule changes, platform decisions and category scepticism has produced something money struggles to buy quickly: a working sense of which channels are durable and which ones evaporate.
That shows up most clearly in what his competitors do. Aaron regularly sees Google Shopping listings running CBD in the title, the image and on the landing page. Agencies have levelled with him about what's behind it. Those brands front-load 50K to six figures a month, sometimes 250K upfront, working with an agency that has a Google rep involved, and they know the listings get pulled in around three months. It buys a quarter of revenue and leaves nothing behind. Bailey's spent the same decade building an events team, an email list, a subscription programme and a push notification base, all of which still work the day a platform changes its rules.
The best acquisition channel is a vendor booth
For 10 years, Bailey's most reliable source of new customers has been turning up in person. There's a dedicated events team that signs up for as many dog events and regional trade shows as it can across Southern California. They run a booth, sell product, talk to owners and build lists with QR codes in exchange for trial size samples. A good Saturday and Sunday brings 100 to 150 new customers. A large home and garden show can bring a few hundred.
What makes it work isn't the volume, it's the handover. The capture goes straight into Klaviyo and the customer walks away with product already in hand. By the time the first email lands, the dog has tried it. That's a warmer starting position than any cold click, and it's why retention picks up so cleanly from there.
Naming the problem changed what sold
Around 6 and a half years ago Bailey's stopped selling general CBD dog treats with 12 potential benefits listed on the pack. Buyers looking at that had nothing specific to act on. Working with their chief veterinarian, Dr Robert J. Silver, the team built solution-based formulations instead: calming products combining tryptophan, chamomile, valerian root and passion flower with CBD, and hip and joint products using turmeric, MSM, green lipped mussels and glucosamine.
Those two categories are now the best sellers by a distance. The formulation work was real, but the commercial shift came from naming the problem. A pet owner watching an ageing dog struggle to stand up isn't shopping for general wellness. They're shopping for hips.
Category education is finally paying back
Six or seven years ago Bailey's spent real budget teaching pet owners what CBD did at all. Aaron now describes general awareness as past a J curve. More than 90% of people, he reckons, immediately connect pet CBD with calming a dog through fireworks. Fourth of July has become a bigger single window than anything in Q4, and Bailey's isn't paying to create that association any more. The brands that stayed in the category long enough to see adoption arrive are the ones collecting on it.
Stacked incentives doing the work of an ad budget
Retention runs on a deliberately layered offer. Subscribe and save has flexible terms from 30 to 180 days, tiered discounts from 15 to 30% depending on volume, and cash back that accumulates as store credit, 3% on one-off purchases and 5 to 6.5% on subscriptions. Customers stock up because the maths rewards it. Push notifications run through the mobile app and a Novel wallet pass, which Aaron says converts strongly whenever they run a flash sale.
Building that stack took work. SMS in particular required finding a cannabis-specific platform and Tailored for iMessage flows, after roughly 15 vendor meetings. Aaron reckons he's taken over 200 software demos in the past year across the business. On a two-person leadership team, that's the cost of running a stack nobody sells off the shelf.
